4 models have responded to the "Michelin Star Recipe Design" challenge. Compare their approaches side-by-side on RIVAL. This response is part of RIVAL's open dataset of 5,600+ AI model responses.
Claude Haiku 4 5's response to the 'Michelin Star Recipe Design' challenge.
Design an innovative recipe for a multi-component dish worthy of a Michelin 3-star restaurant. The recipe should feature an unusual ingredient pairing, advanced culinary techniques, and exquisite plating presentation. Provide detailed instructions for each component, sourcing notes for specialized ingredients (if any), and the conceptual narrative behind the dish.
This dish explores the intersection of Japanese fermentation philosophy and Nordic minimalism, using koji (aspergillus oryzae mold) as a bridge between cultures and flavor dimensions. The narrative arc moves from deep, funky umami through mineral-bright acidity to a shocking sweetness—mirroring a night sky transitioning from dusk to stars to dawn. It challenges diners' expectations of what "savory" means.
Ingredients:
Technique: Enzymatic Curing via Koji Fermentation
Koji Culture Preparation: Mix koji spores with salt and miso powder. The miso provides essential nutrients; the salt controls fermentation speed.
Application: Create a thin, even paste coating the entire scallop surface. Place on parchment in a humidity-controlled chamber (65% humidity, 18°C).
Fermentation Monitoring:
Finishing: Briefly torch the surface (3 seconds) to create a 1mm crust while preserving the raw interior. This creates textural contrast and prevents oxidation.
Sourcing Notes:
Ingredients:
Technique: Warm Emulsion Using Miso as Emulsifier
Miso Dissolution: Whisk miso and dashi off-heat until completely smooth; this prevents seizing.
Emulsification: Using an immersion blender at medium speed, slowly drizzle brown butter into miso mixture while blending continuously. The lecithin in miso acts as a natural emulsifier.
Stabilization: Add xanthan gum in a slurry (mixed with cold water first) to prevent separation during service. Strain through fine chinois.
Temperature Control: Maintain at 60-65°C; above 70°C, the emulsion breaks.
Toasted Nori Oil (Made 2 hours prior):
Ingredients:
Technique: Lacto-Fermentation + Koji Enzymatic Breakdown
Initial Fermentation: Toss celery root cubes with salt; pack into anaerobic container. Ferment at 18°C for 4 days. This develops lactic acid and complex flavor.
Koji Inoculation: On day 4, drain liquid, dust with koji spores, and allow aerobic fermentation for 2-3 days at 20°C, 70% humidity. Koji enzymes convert celery's starches to glucose, creating subtle sweetness that contrasts savory elements.
Cooking: Steam fermented celery root until completely tender (12 minutes).
Puréeing: Blend with vegetable stock and butter until silken; pass through tamis. The texture should be cloud-like.
Seasoning: Adjust salt; add white pepper for subtle heat without flavor distraction.
Ingredients:
Technique: Curing + Spherification-Adjacent Method
Dry Cure: Mix koji powder, salt, and sugar. Bury egg yolks completely in mixture; refrigerate 24 hours.
Rinsing: Gently rinse yolks under cool water; pat dry carefully.
Spherification: Using a specialized spherification spoon (or careful hands), gently lower each yolk into 75°C oil for exactly 90 seconds. The exterior sets into a delicate shell while the interior remains liquid.
Draining: Place on paper towels; serve immediately or hold at 55°C maximum 20 minutes.
Result: A bite releases umami-rich koji-cured yolk with a crispy exterior—textural and flavor surprise.
Ingredients:
Technique: Smoke-Infused Gel with Mineral Suspension
Dashi Preparation: Make primary dashi (kombu 2 hours, then 8 minutes bonito flakes). Secondary dashi uses spent bonito for deeper flavor.
Smoking: Introduce liquid smoke drop-by-drop while tasting; it should be a whisper, not a shout. The smoke adds dimension without overwhelming.
Gelification: Heat dashi to 70°C, whisk in agar-agar thoroughly to avoid lumps. Bring to boil for 1 minute.
Seasoning: Add yuzu juice and salt; taste for balance between umami, acidity, and mineral quality.
Setting: Pour into shallow container; cool to room temperature, then refrigerate 2 hours until set.
Plating Preparation: Cut into small cubes (5mm) or use spherification technique for elegant dots.
Ingredients:
Technique: Tuile-Style Crisp with Umami Layering
Dough: Mix koji powder, cheese, butter, rice flour, and miso into a paste. Fold in charred scallion and cayenne.
Spreading: Spread extremely thin (1-2mm) on silicone mat in 3cm x 8cm rectangles.
Baking: 160°C for 8-10 minutes until golden and crisp. Remove while warm; they'll crisp further as they cool.
Charring Allium: Char scallion whites directly over flame until blackened; mince fine. This adds smoke and depth without overwhelming delicacy.
Ingredients:
Technique: Spherification for Textural Surprise
Pickling: Slice cucumber into thin rounds; pickle in vinegar solution with dill and mustard seeds for 3 days at 4°C.
Spherification Bath: Prepare sodium alginate bath (0.5% solution); let sit 24 hours to remove air bubbles.
Sphere Creation: Using a small spoon or pipette, drop pickled cucumber brine (strained) into calcium chloride bath (2% solution). Spheres will form instantly.
Dill Oil: Blanch dill 10 seconds, shock in ice water, squeeze dry, blend with grapeseed oil, strain through cheesecloth.
Ingredients:
Preparation: Mix all dry elements; use as textural and aromatic garnish.
White, shallow 28cm ceramic with slight depression; temperature 55°C.
Foundation (5 o'clock position): Spoon 15ml fermented celery root purée in small mound; create gentle slope with back of spoon.
Protein Placement (12 o'clock): Position koji-cured scallop on top of purée, angled slightly. The scallop should be the visual anchor.
Emulsion Artistry (3 o'clock): Spoon 8ml brown butter-miso emulsion in small dots (3-4) around the plate, using tweezers to place with precision.
Gelée Placement: Arrange 4-5 smoked dashi gelée cubes in a loose line from 2 to 4 o'clock, creating visual rhythm.
Crispy Yolk (1 o'clock): Place koji-cured egg yolk on a small mound of celery purée, creating height variation.
Wafer Architecture: Stand koji wafer vertically behind the scallop, leaning slightly—this creates drama and height.
Pickle Sphere: Place pickled cucumber sphere (drained) at 6 o'clock, nestled against purée.
Oil Drizzle: Using squeeze bottle, create thin lines of toasted nori oil across plate, moving from protein outward.
Herb Oil: Dribble dill oil (3-4 small dots) near pickle sphere.
Dust and Garnish:
Final Touch: Micro shiso leaf or dill frond placed on scallop for freshness indicator.
The plate should read as:
Temperature Protocol:
Timing: This dish requires 90 seconds of final plating. Communicate with kitchen to ensure all components are ready simultaneously.
Wine Pairing Recommendation: A mineral-driven white with slight oxidation (Jura Savagnin or aged Riesling) echoes the koji fermentation and bright acidity.
| Component | Ingredient | Supplier | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Koji Spores | Aspergillus oryzae | GEM Cultures, Fermentationculture.eu | Food-grade, organic certified |
| Scallop | Diver scallop | Local sustainable fishery | Avoid farmed; request same-day delivery |
| Miso | Aka miso, white miso | Marukame Udon, Nakagin | Unpasteurized preferred |
| Nori | Grade A Yaki nori | Kenko Foods | Toasted, premium quality |
| Dashi | Kombu, bonito flakes | Kenko Foods, Umami Mart | Hokkaido kombu, Ito Suisan bonito |
| Koji Powder | Dehydrated koji | Gem Cultures, DIY dehydration | Dehydrate fresh koji at 40°C |
Why Koji? Koji transforms this dish from a simple scallop preparation into a meditation on umami development. The enzymatic breakdown of proteins into amino acids (particularly glutamate) creates a flavor depth that rivals aged cheeses or fermented products, but with a delicate, almost floral quality unique to koji.
The Fermentation Philosophy By using koji on both the scallop AND in the celery root purée, we create a harmonic relationship—the koji notes resonate throughout the dish, creating cohesion while the other elements (smoke, acidity, brightness) provide contrast.
Why These Pairings Work
This dish celebrates fermentation as both technique and philosophy—the idea that transformation through time and microbial action creates something greater than the sum of its parts. It's simultaneously deeply Japanese (koji, dashi, miso) and resolutely modern (spherification, smoke infusion, enzymatic curing), challenging the diner's assumptions about what "Japanese cuisine" means while honoring its fundamental principles.
The koji-cured scallop may be the most innovative element: by using the same organism that creates sake, miso, and soy sauce, we're connecting the diner to centuries of fermentation tradition while presenting something entirely new.
Turn this model response into notes, narration, or a short video
Partner link