4 models have responded to the "Michelin Star Recipe Design" challenge. Compare their approaches side-by-side on RIVAL. This response is part of RIVAL's open dataset of 5,600+ AI model responses.
Kimi K2's response to the 'Michelin Star Recipe Design' challenge.
Design an innovative recipe for a multi-component dish worthy of a Michelin 3-star restaurant. The recipe should feature an unusual ingredient pairing, advanced culinary techniques, and exquisite plating presentation. Provide detailed instructions for each component, sourcing notes for specialized ingredients (if any), and the conceptual narrative behind the dish.
Dish Title
“White Forest: Coal-Kissed Pine, Malted Vanilla Snow & Fermented Moss”
Conceptual Narrative
This plate is a walk through a winter-birch forest at twilight: the air is resinous from pine, the soil smells faintly of smoke and cocoa, and a single ray of moonlight gilds the frost. The menu’s “White Forest” is therefore monochrome in hue but explosive in aroma—an inversion of the classic Black Forest cake. Instead of chocolate and cherry we pair white pine, charcoal-barley koji, and black birch sap. The guest is invited to smell the forest (a warm pine-infused vapor released tableside) before tasting the cold, sweet, bitter and mineral layers that follow.
Unusual Pairing
• White-pine cambium (the tender inner bark) wrapped around a black-birch-sap caramel
• Malted vanilla “snow” aerated with liquid nitrogen and infused with toasted yeast to give beer-like umami
• Fermented reindeer moss marinated in birch-syrup koji, then brûléed—its lichenous crunch echoes the pine bark while the koji introduces chocolate/malt notes that never actually contain chocolate.
Advanced Techniques
Sourcing Notes
• Fresh white-pine cambium: harvest from storm-felled trees in late winter (legal on private land with permission). Freeze immediately; cambium oxidizes in minutes.
• Reindeer moss (Cladonia rangiferina): food-grade dried from Nordic wild foragers (e.g., Nordisk Tang, DK). Rehydrate in 3 % salt + 1 % glucose.
• Barley koji spores: Hishiroku “Chōhaku-kin” white strain for sweet aroma.
• Black birch sap: early-spring tap, sterile-filtered and vacuum-reduced to 60 °Brix syrup.
• Liquid nitrogen: restaurant supply or university food-science partnership.
Yield
One plated portion (à la carte) or 8 tasting-menu bites if served as a canapé.
COMPONENT A: Coal-Kissed Pine Bark Cylinder
Purpose – The “tree trunk” element; visually a pale log, but once cracked open it oozes a dark birch caramel that resembles sap bleeding from a charcoal scar.
Ingredients
• 40 g fresh white-pine cambium sheet (8 × 20 cm, 2 mm thick)
• 60 g black-birch-sap caramel (60 °Brix syrup cooked to 118 °C with 0.2 % pectin NH)
• 0.5 g activated charcoal powder (food grade)
• 0.5 g sea salt smoked over pine needles
Method
COMPONENT B: Malted Vanilla Snow
Purpose – Cold, aromatic “powder” that dissolves on the tongue leaving vanilla & toasted-yeast malt.
Ingredients
• 100 g birch-syrup koji (see below)
• 200 g whole milk
• 50 g heavy cream (36 %)
• 3 g Maldon salt
• 1 Tahitian vanilla bean, scraped
• 0.6 g gellan gum LT100
• 1 g toasted deactivated brewer’s yeast (180 °C/10 min)
Method (the night before)
COMPONENT C: Fermented Reindeer Moss Brûlée
Purpose – Forest-floor crunch with caramelized lichen bitterness.
Ingredients
• 4 g dried reindeer moss
• 40 g birch-syrup koji (same as above)
• 5 g pine-needle oil (cold-pressed)
• 1 g glucose syrup
Method
COMPONENT D: Charcoal-Barley Koji “Soil”
Purpose – Edible earth that releases a deep smoky malt when warmed by the plate.
Ingredients
• 40 g pearled barley, steamed
• 0.2 g koji spores
• 3 g binchotan charcoal dust (food grade)
• 1 g cocoa butter
Method (72 h total)
COMPONENT E: Pine-Needle Vapor
Purpose – Aroma trigger; when the plate is set down a server pours 50 °C water onto a compressed pine-needle and cedar-bark “tea bag” hidden beneath. Steam carries the scent upward without affecting the food temperature.
ASSEMBLY & PLATING
Service Notes
• Timing: bark cylinder must temper 90 s at room temperature so the caramel is fluid when cracked by the guest’s spoon.
• Provide a warm spoon; contrast amplifies.
• Wine pairing: 1989 Côteaux du Layon “Clos de la Coulée de Serrant” (honeyed but laser acidity to cut koji umami and vanilla).
All components are gluten-free except for the barley koji; substitute buckwheat if needed.
Turn this model response into notes, narration, or a short video
Partner link