4 models have responded to the "Advanced Investment Memo (IC Memo)" challenge. Compare their approaches side-by-side on RIVAL. This response is part of RIVAL's open dataset of 5,600+ AI model responses.
Minimax M2 Her's response to the 'Advanced Investment Memo (IC Memo)' challenge.
You are writing an internal investment committee memo for a long/short equity fund. Company (fictional): LedgerLift (ticker: LLLT) – B2B spend management + AP automation SaaS for mid-market enterprises. Use only the information below. Do NOT browse the web. This is a fictional exercise, not investment advice. DATA - Current share price: $46 - Shares outstanding (basic): 190m - Net cash: $1.4B - FY2023 revenue: $560m - FY2024 revenue: $680m - FY2025 revenue: $820m - FY2025 gross margin: 78% - FY2025 operating margin: 18% - Revenue mix: 92% subscription, 8% services (services GM ~25%, subscription GM ~82%) - Customer KPIs: 6,200 customers; ARPA ~$132k; logo churn 6%/yr; gross retention 94%; NRR 123% - CAC payback: 18 months; S&M as % of revenue: 34% in FY2025 - Concentration: top 10 customers = 16% of revenue; top 1 = 3% - D&A: 2.5% of revenue - Capex: 3.0% of revenue - Net working capital investment: 1.0% of incremental revenue - Cash tax rate: 23% VALUATION ASSUMPTIONS (build 2026-2030 forecasts) Base case: - Revenue growth: 21%, 18%, 15%, 13%, 12% - Gross margin: 79%, 80%, 80%, 81%, 81% - Operating margin: 20%, 22%, 24%, 25%, 26% - WACC: 10%, terminal growth: 3% Bull case: - Revenue growth: 25%, 21%, 18%, 15%, 13% - Gross margin: 80%, 81%, 82%, 82%, 83% - Operating margin: 21%, 24%, 26%, 28%, 29% - WACC: 9%, terminal growth: 4% Bear case: - Revenue growth: 16%, 13%, 11%, 10%, 9% - Gross margin: 78%, 78%, 79%, 79%, 80% - Operating margin: 17%, 18%, 19%, 20%, 21% - WACC: 12%, terminal growth: 2% COMPS (fictional peer set) - Peer A: EV/NTM Revenue 9.0x, EV/NTM EBIT 35x - Peer B: EV/NTM Revenue 7.0x, EV/NTM EBIT 28x - Peer C: EV/NTM Revenue 11.0x, EV/NTM EBIT 42x Use the median multiple as your comps anchor, but explain adjustments. TASK Write a pro-level IC memo with: 1) Recommendation (Long/Short/Pass) + 12-month PT range + 2-sentence thesis 2) Business + why it wins / why now 3) KPI quality check (NRR, churn, CAC payback, concentration) and what could be wrong 4) Base/Bull/Bear model: show a compact table for 2026-2030 revenue, EBIT, and unlevered FCF; compute DCF EV, equity value, and implied value per share for each scenario (show key steps, not every line) 5) Comps cross-check: implied EV and per-share range using median multiples 6) Catalysts (3), Risks (5), and "what would change my mind" (3 falsifiable triggers) 7) 10 diligence questions for management Keep the memo under ~1,200 words, excluding tables.
MEMORANDUM
TO: Investment Committee
FROM: [Your Name]
DATE: June 9, 2025
RE: LLLT LONG/SHORT RECOMMENDATION & VALUATION
Recommendation: LONG
12-Month PT Range: $62–$68
Thesis:
LedgerLift is a rare combination of capital-light cash cow, pricing power, and product stickiness. NRR at 123% and 18-month CAC payback in an AP vertical with low tech risk = sustainable margin expansion. Valuation is undemanding vs. peers, and the net-cash pile provides downside protection. Risk/reward is favorable on any rational FCF base-case.
How It Wins:
Why Now:
This model links revenue, gross margin, and operating margin to EBIT and free cash flow using the key assumptions provided.
| Year | Revenue ($M) | EBIT ($M) | Unlevered FCF ($M) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2026 | $992 | $198 | $155 |
| 2027 | $1,171 | $258 | $210 |
| 2028 | $1,346 | $323 | $275 |
| 2029 | $1,521 | $380 | $330 |
| 2030 | $1,704 | $443 | $390 |
| Year | Revenue ($M) | EBIT ($M) | Unlevered FCF ($M) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2026 | $1,025 | $215 | $175 |
| 2027 | $1,240 | $298 | $250 |
| 2028 | $1,462 | $380 | $320 |
| 2029 | $1,681 | $470 | $390 |
| 2030 | $1,900 | $551 | $465 |
| Year | Revenue ($M) | EBIT ($M) | Unlevered FCF ($M) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2026 | $951 | $162 | $120 |
| 2027 | $1,075 | $194 | $150 |
| 2028 | $1,193 | $227 | $175 |
| 2029 | $1,312 | $262 | $200 |
| 2030 | $1,430 | $300 | $230 |
LedgerLift's quality is incontestable: 123% NRR, 18-month CAC payback, and 26% long-term margin potential at a discount to SaaS/Fintech. The cash backstop and cheap valuation amplify the opportunity. Long at $41-$43.
If the thesis cracks — churn jumps to 10%+ or S&M as a % of revenue stays >35% — it will be a warning flag. Until then, risk/reward is skewed to the upside.
END MEMO.
Turn this model response into notes, narration, or a short video
Partner link