4 models have responded to the "Michelin Star Recipe Design" challenge. Compare their approaches side-by-side on RIVAL. This response is part of RIVAL's open dataset of 5,600+ AI model responses.
Claude Opus 4 5's response to the 'Michelin Star Recipe Design' challenge.
Design an innovative recipe for a multi-component dish worthy of a Michelin 3-star restaurant. The recipe should feature an unusual ingredient pairing, advanced culinary techniques, and exquisite plating presentation. Provide detailed instructions for each component, sourcing notes for specialized ingredients (if any), and the conceptual narrative behind the dish.
This dish explores the liminal space where ocean meets shore—that precise moment when a wave retreats and leaves behind its treasures. The unusual pairing of Hokkaido sea urchin with white chocolate challenges the diner's expectations, using the chocolate's dairy sweetness to amplify the uni's oceanic butteriness while creating a cognitive dissonance that resolves into harmony.
The narrative unfolds in three "tidal movements":
Each bite should transport the guest to standing barefoot on cold morning sand, watching the Pacific recede.
| Component | Technique | Purpose |
|---|---|---|
| Sea Urchin & White Chocolate Velouté | Emulsification, spherification | Base sauce, umami-sweet foundation |
| Kombu-Cured Hokkaido Scallop | Kobujime curing | Textural protein, oceanic depth |
| Sea Buckthorn Gel | Fluid gel technology | Acidity, brightness, coastal terroir |
| Smoked Dulse Tuile | Dehydration, smoking | Texture, visual drama |
| Samphire & Coastal Herb Salad | Precise blanching, raw elements | Freshness, vegetal contrast |
| Frozen White Chocolate "Sand" | Cryogenic freezing | Temperature play, textural surprise |
| Dashi Air | Lecithin aeration | Aromatic ephemeral element |
| Sea Salt Crystals (Maldon, smoked) | Finishing | Seasoning, crunch |
The heart of the dish—where the unusual pairing lives
Yield: 8 portions | Prep: 45 min | Difficulty: Advanced
Ingredients:
Method:
Prepare the dashi base: Combine 500ml soft water with 15g kombu. Cold-steep for 12 hours. Bring to 60°C/140°F, remove kombu. Add 20g katsuobushi, steep 4 minutes, strain through coffee filter. Reserve 150ml.
Create the chocolate liaison: Gently melt white chocolate to exactly 40°C/104°F using a bain-marie. This temperature prevents fat separation and maintains emulsification capacity.
Build the velouté:
Finish the sauce:
Reserve remaining 50g uni for plating (pristine whole lobes)
Chef's Notes:
72-hour cure for concentrated oceanic essence
Yield: 8 portions | Prep: 15 min active, 72 hours curing
Ingredients:
Method:
Prepare kombu: Lightly wipe with damp cloth (do not wash—preserve the white umami powder). Brush both sides with sake.
Prepare scallops: Remove side muscle. Pat completely dry. Season lightly with fine salt.
First cure (Day 1): Place scallops between kombu sheets in a single layer. Wrap tightly in plastic film, eliminating all air. Place between two sheet pans with 2kg weight on top. Refrigerate.
Turn and refresh (Day 2): Unwrap, flip scallops, brush kombu with mirin. Rewrap with fresh plastic. Continue weighted cure.
Final rest (Day 3): Remove weight for final 12 hours. The scallops should be firm but yielding, with a translucent, amber-tinged appearance.
Slice for service: Using a very sharp yanagiba, slice each scallop horizontally into 3 discs (approximately 8mm thick). Reserve between damp towels.
Chef's Notes:
Fluid gel technique for perfect sauce behavior
Yield: 200g | Prep: 30 min plus setting
Ingredients:
Method:
Combine purée, syrup, and agar in a saucepan. Whisk thoroughly.
Bring to a full boil, whisking constantly. Boil for 2 minutes to fully hydrate agar.
Pour into a flat container to set (approximately 1cm depth). Refrigerate until firm (minimum 2 hours).
Cut set gel into cubes. Transfer to a high-powered blender.
Blend on high for 3-4 minutes, scraping down sides, until perfectly smooth with no granular texture. The gel should be pourable but hold its shape when piped.
Pass through a fine sieve. Season with ascorbic acid and salt.
Transfer to a squeeze bottle. Refrigerate.
Chef's Notes:
Architectural element with deep umami
Yield: 16 tuiles | Prep: 45 min plus dehydration
Ingredients:
Method:
Rehydrate dulse: Soak in cold water for 10 minutes. Drain, squeeze dry, and roughly chop.
Create batter: Blend dulse with dashi until smooth. Strain, pressing to extract liquid. Whisk liquid with tapioca starch and oil until no lumps remain.
Form tuiles: On silicone-lined dehydrator trays, spread batter into thin, organic wave shapes (approximately 8cm × 3cm, 2mm thick). Use an offset spatula.
Dehydrate: Set dehydrator to 55°C/131°F. Dry for 8-10 hours until completely crisp and translucent.
Cold smoke: Arrange tuiles on a perforated tray. Cold smoke with applewood for 15 minutes using a smoking gun in a covered container.
Store: Keep in an airtight container with silica gel packets. Use within 24 hours.
Chef's Notes:
Raw and blanched elements for textural contrast
Yield: 8 portions | Prep: 20 min
Ingredients:
For Lemon Oil:
Method:
Prepare samphire: Trim woody ends. Blanch in heavily salted boiling water for exactly 45 seconds. Shock in ice water. Drain on paper towels.
Prepare other elements: Keep sea purslane, oyster leaves, ice plant, and fennel fronds raw. Store between damp paper towels until plating.
Dress at service: Toss samphire lightly with lemon oil. Season other elements with a few drops of oil and fleur de sel.
Chef's Notes:
Cryogenic technique for temperature contrast
Yield: 200g | Prep: 30 min
Ingredients:
Method:
Create chocolate powder: Melt white chocolate to 40°C/104°F. In a food processor, combine maltodextrin and coconut powder. With processor running, slowly drizzle in melted chocolate. Process until it forms a dry, sandy powder.
Season: Pulse in ground Maldon salt.
Freeze at service: Working quickly, place chocolate sand in a metal bowl. Carefully pour liquid nitrogen over the sand while stirring with a metal spoon. Continue until sand reaches approximately -40°C/-40°F.
Plate immediately: The sand will hold its frozen state for approximately 90 seconds at room temperature.
Chef's Notes:
Ephemeral aromatic element
Yield: 500ml foam | Prep: 10 min
Ingredients:
Method:
Combine dashi, lecithin, and white soy in a deep container.
Using an immersion blender tilted at the surface, aerate the liquid by blending at the air-liquid interface.
Continue until a thick layer of stable bubbles forms (approximately 3-4 minutes).
Let rest 30 seconds. Skim the top layer of fine, stable bubbles for plating.
Chef's Notes:
| Ingredient | Source Recommendation | Substitution |
|---|---|---|
| Hokkaido Uni | Maruhide Marine (Santa Barbara) or direct from Hokkaido via Regalis Foods | Santa Barbara uni (slightly sweeter, less briny) |
| Hokkaido Scallops | True World Foods, Browne Trading Co. | Maine diver scallops (ensure dry-packed) |
| Valrhona Ivoire | Professional pastry suppliers, Valrhona direct | Callebaut W2 (higher sugar, adjust accordingly) |
| Ma-Kombu | Mitsuwa, Japanese grocery, or Umami Insider | Any high-grade kombu; avoid thin varieties |
| Sea Buckthorn Purée | Perfect Purée of Napa Valley, Boiron | Fresh berries (in season), passion fruit + citrus (different but workable) |
| Dulse | Maine Coast Sea Vegetables, Atlantic Holdfast | Nori (less complex flavor) |
| Samphire | Specialty produce (Baldor, FreshPoint), coastal foragers | Thin haricots verts (blanched), sea beans |
| Oyster Leaves, Sea Purslane | Koppert Cress, local foragers | Purslane, micro herbs |
| Tapioca Maltodextrin | Modernist Pantry, WillPowder | N-Zorbit M (identical product) |
Vessel: Custom-made shallow bowl in matte white ceramic with an undulating, tide-pool-inspired depression (approximately 25cm diameter). Alternatively, a wide, shallow slate plate.
The Composition (12 o'clock facing guest):
[Dashi Air - ethereal cloud, 2 o'clock]
○ ○ ○
○ ○ ○ ○
[Dulse Tuile - [Frozen Sand -
standing wave, crescent sweep,
10 o'clock] 4-5 o'clock]
╱ ░░░░
╱ ░░░░░░
╱ ░░░░░░░░
◉ ◉ ◉ [Scallop discs -
◉ ◉ ◉ overlapping, center]
◉ ◉ ◉
[Sea Buckthorn ════════════ [Velouté -
Gel - dots, ════════════ poured tableside,
scattered ════════════ pool beneath
6-8 o'clock] scallops]
• • •
• •
[Uni Lobes - 2 pristine pieces,
nestled at 7 o'clock]
🟠 🟠
[Herb Salad - naturalistic scatter across plate,
avoiding center pool]
🌿 🌿 🌿
🌿 🌿
Plating Sequence:
Frozen sand first: Using a small offset spatula, create a crescent sweep of frozen sand along the 4-5 o'clock position. Work quickly.
Scallop arrangement: Shingle 3 scallop discs in the center, slightly overlapping like scales or shells.
Uni placement: Nestle 2 pristine uni lobes at 7 o'clock, just touching the scallop arrangement.
Sea buckthorn dots: Using squeeze bottle, place 5-7 small dots of gel in an organic scatter (6-8 o'clock).
Herb salad: Arrange samphire, sea purslane, oyster leaves, ice plant, and fennel fronds in a naturalistic scatter, as if washed up by a wave. Avoid covering the scallops or uni.
Dulse tuile: Lean one tuile vertically against the scallop arrangement at 10 o'clock, creating height and drama.
Dashi air: Spoon a cloud of dashi air at 2 o'clock, allowing some bubbles to drift toward center.
Tableside finish: Bring the warm velouté in a small copper pot. Pour approximately 50ml around (not over) the scallops, allowing it to pool beneath and around the composition.
Final touch: Finish with 3-4 Maldon flakes and one pinch of smoked salt over the uni.
Temperature Considerations:
Timing:
Guest Guidance: The captain should explain: "We invite you to begin with the sea urchin and a touch of the velouté to experience the central pairing. Then explore the plate freely—the frozen sand will melt, the air will dissipate, and the dish will evolve as you eat, just as the tide transforms the shore."
Wine Pairing Suggestion:
3 Days Before:
1 Day Before:
Day of Service:
This dish succeeds when the diner experiences genuine surprise followed by recognition—the white chocolate-uni pairing should feel impossible until it feels inevitable. The technical elements serve the narrative: the frozen sand melting into sweetness, the air disappearing like sea spray, the tuile shattering like dried kelp underfoot.
The true Michelin 3-star quality lies not in complexity for its own sake, but in the emotional transportation of the guest. When executed properly, "Tidal Memory" should make someone close their eyes and smell the ocean, even in a landlocked dining room.
"Cooking is about transformation—of ingredients, yes, but ultimately of the person eating."
Turn this model response into notes, narration, or a short video
Partner link