4 models have responded to the "Mini LBO Underwrite" challenge. Compare their approaches side-by-side on RIVAL. This response is part of RIVAL's open dataset of 5,600+ AI model responses.
Deepseek V3 2's response to the 'Mini LBO Underwrite' challenge.
You are underwriting a 5-year LBO for a private equity investment committee. Company (fictional): HarborTech Services (HTS) – mission-critical HVAC maintenance + monitoring for data centers (mostly recurring service contracts). Use only the information below. Do NOT browse the web. This is a fictional exercise. ENTRY (close at end of FY2025) - FY2025 revenue: $900m - FY2025 EBITDA: $120m (13.3% margin) - Purchase price: 12.0x EBITDA - Transaction fees: 2.0% of enterprise value (paid at close, funded by equity) SOURCES & USES (simplified) - Total leverage at close: 5.5x EBITDA - Term Loan: 4.0x EBITDA, 9.0% cash interest, 1.0% annual amortization - Mezzanine: 1.5x EBITDA, 12.0% cash interest + 2.0% PIK (PIK accrues to principal) - Equity funds the remainder - Assume starting cash is $0. - Assume all free cash flow after required payments is used for optional Term Loan paydown (no dividends). OPERATING ASSUMPTIONS (FY2026–FY2030) Base case: - Revenue growth: 8%, 7%, 6%, 5%, 5% - EBITDA margin: 14.0%, 15.0%, 16.0%, 16.5%, 17.0% - Capex: 3.0% of revenue - Change in NWC: 0.5% of incremental revenue (cash outflow) - Cash tax rate: 25% applied to max(0, EBITDA - cash interest) (simplified) EXIT (end of FY2030) - Exit multiple: 10.5x FY2030 EBITDA - Exit fees: 1.0% of enterprise value - Mezzanine (including PIK) is repaid at exit. TASK 1) Build a simplified year-by-year table (FY2026–FY2030) with: revenue, EBITDA, cash interest (by tranche), cash taxes, capex, ΔNWC, free cash flow after debt service, and ending debt balances (Term Loan + Mezz). 2) Compute equity IRR and MOIC. 3) Provide a sensitivity table of equity IRR vs exit multiple (9.5x / 10.5x / 11.5x) and exit-year EBITDA margin (16% / 17% / 18%). 4) List 5 underwriting risks and 5 concrete downside protection levers. Keep it concise, but show the math clearly.
Alright — let’s go step by step.
EBITDA = $120m
Purchase price = 12.0 × EBITDA = $1,440m
Enterprise Value (EV) = $1,440m (assumed purchase price = EV here)
Transaction fees = 2.0% × EV = $28.8m (funded by equity).
Total debt at close = 5.5 × EBITDA = $660m
Term Loan: 4.0 × EBITDA = $480m
Mezzanine: 1.5 × EBITDA = $180m
Equity contribution = Purchase price + fees − total debt
= $1,440m + $28.8m − $660m = $808.8m initial equity.
Starting cash $0.
Revenue growth:
FY2025 base = $900m
FY2026: ×1.08 = $972m
FY2027: ×1.07 = $1,040.04m
FY2028: ×1.06 = $1,102.44m
FY2029: ×1.05 = $1,157.56m
FY2030: ×1.05 = $1,215.44m
EBITDA margin:
FY2026: 14.0% → $136.08m
FY2027: 15.0% → $156.01m
FY2028: 16.0% → $176.39m
FY2029: 16.5% → $191.00m
FY2030: 17.0% → $206.62m
Capex: 3% of revenue each year.
ΔNWC: 0.5% of incremental revenue (cash outflow if revenue grows).
Interest:
Term Loan: 9.0% cash interest on beginning balance, 1% annual amortization of initial principal ($4.8m/year).
Mezzanine: 12.0% cash interest on beginning balance, plus 2.0% PIK added to principal (no cash out).
Cash taxes: 25% × max(0, EBITDA − cash interest).
Debt paydown: All FCF after required payments used for optional Term Loan paydown (after mandatory amortization).
Starting balances (end FY2025):
Term Loan = $480.0m
Mezz = $180.0m
Mezz PIK accrual: 2.0% × beginning balance added to principal each year before interest calc for next year.
Term Loan mandatory amortization: $4.8m/year.
FY2026:
Revenue = $972m
EBITDA = $136.08m
Capex = $29.16m
ΔNWC = 0.5% × ($972m − $900m) = 0.005 × $72m = $0.36m
Cash interest:
Term Loan: 9% × $480m = $43.20m
Mezz: 12% × $180m = $21.60m
Total cash interest = $64.80m
EBIT (approx) = EBITDA − D&A (not given, but taxes based on EBITDA − cash interest):
Taxable = max(0, $136.08m − $64.80m) = $71.28m
Cash tax = 25% × $71.28m = $17.82m
FCF before debt paydown:
EBITDA − cash interest − cash taxes − capex − ΔNWC
= $136.08m − $64.80m − $17.82m − $29.16m − $0.36m = $23.94m
Mandatory amortization Term Loan = $4.8m
Optional paydown = $23.94m
Ending Term Loan = $480m − $4.8m − $23.94m = $451.26m
Mezz ending (before PIK) = $180m
PIK = 2% × $180m = $3.6m → Mezz principal = $183.6m
FY2027:
Revenue = $1,040.04m
EBITDA = $156.01m
Capex = $31.20m
ΔNWC = 0.5% × ($1,040.04m − $972m) = 0.005 × $68.04m = $0.34m
Cash interest:
Term Loan: 9% × $451.26m = $40.61m
Mezz: 12% × $183.6m = $22.03m
Total = $62.64m
Taxable = max(0, $156.01m − $62.64m) = $93.37m
Cash tax = $23.34m
FCF before optional paydown:
$156.01m − $62.64m − $23.34m − $31.20m − $0.34m = $38.49m
Mandatory amortization = $4.8m
Optional paydown = $38.49m
End Term Loan = $451.26m − $4.8m − $38.49m = $407.97m
Mezz before PIK = $183.6m
PIK = 2% × $183.6m = $3.672m → Mezz = $187.27m
FY2028:
Revenue = $1,102.44m
EBITDA = $176.39m
Capex = $33.07m
ΔNWC = 0.5% × ($1,102.44m − $1,040.04m) = 0.005 × $62.40m = $0.312m ≈ $0.31m
Cash interest:
Term Loan: 9% × $407.97m = $36.72m
Mezz: 12% × $187.27m = $22.47m
Total = $59.19m
Taxable = $176.39m − $59.19m = $117.20m
Cash tax = $29.30m
FCF before optional paydown:
$176.39m − $59.19m − $29.30m − $33.07m − $0.31m = $54.52m
Mandatory amortization = $4.8m
Optional paydown = $54.52m
End Term Loan = $407.97m − $4.8m − $54.52m = $348.65m
Mezz before PIK = $187.27m
PIK = 2% × $187.27m = $3.745m → Mezz = $191.02m
FY2029:
Revenue = $1,157.56m
EBITDA = $191.00m
Capex = $34.73m
ΔNWC = 0.5% × ($1,157.56m − $1,102.44m) = 0.005 × $55.12m = $0.276m ≈ $0.28m
Cash interest:
Term Loan: 9% × $348.65m = $31.38m
Mezz: 12% × $191.02m = $22.92m
Total = $54.30m
Taxable = $191.00m − $54.30m = $136.70m
Cash tax = $34.18m
FCF before optional paydown:
$191.00m − $54.30m − $34.18m − $34.73m − $0.28m = $67.51m
Mandatory amortization = $4.8m
Optional paydown = $67.51m
End Term Loan = $348.65m − $4.8m − $67.51m = $276.34m
Mezz before PIK = $191.02m
PIK = 2% × $191.02m = $3.82m → Mezz = $194.84m
FY2030:
Revenue = $1,215.44m
EBITDA = $206.62m
Capex = $36.46m
ΔNWC = 0.5% × ($1,215.44m − $1,157.56m) = 0.005 × $57.88m = $0.289m ≈ $0.29m
Cash interest:
Term Loan: 9% × $276.34m = $24.87m
Mezz: 12% × $194.84m = $23.38m
Total = $48.25m
Taxable = $206.62m − $48.25m = $158.37m
Cash tax = $39.59m
FCF before optional paydown:
$206.62m − $48.25m − $39.59m − $36.46m − $0.29m = $82.03m
Mandatory amortization = $4.8m
Optional paydown = $82.03m
End Term Loan = $276.34m − $4.8m − $82.03m = $189.51m
Mezz before PIK = $194.84m
PIK = 2% × $194.84m = $3.897m → Mezz = $198.74m
Summary table FY2026–2030 ($m):
| Item | FY2026 | FY2027 | FY2028 | FY2029 | FY2030 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Revenue | 972.00 | 1,040.04 | 1,102.44 | 1,157.56 | 1,215.44 |
| EBITDA | 136.08 | 156.01 | 176.39 | 191.00 | 206.62 |
| Cash Int Term | 43.20 | 40.61 | 36.72 | 31.38 | 24.87 |
| Cash Int Mezz | 21.60 | 22.03 | 22.47 | 22.92 | 23.38 |
| Total Cash Int | 64.80 | 62.64 | 59.19 | 54.30 | 48.25 |
| Cash Taxes | 17.82 | 23.34 | 29.30 | 34.18 | 39.59 |
| Capex | 29.16 | 31.20 | 33.07 | 34.73 | 36.46 |
| ΔNWC | 0.36 | 0.34 | 0.31 | 0.28 | 0.29 |
| FCF after debt* | 23.94 | 38.49 | 54.52 | 67.51 | 82.03 |
| End Term Loan | 451.26 | 407.97 | 348.65 | 276.34 | 189.51 |
| End Mezz | 183.60 | 187.27 | 191.02 | 194.84 | 198.74 |
*FCF after debt service = after mandatory amortization + interest + taxes − capex − ΔNWC; all used for optional paydown.
Exit FY2030 EBITDA = $206.62m
Exit multiple = 10.5× → EV = $2,169.51m
Exit fees = 1% × EV = $21.70m
Net debt at exit:
Term Loan = $189.51m
Mezz = $198.74m
Cash = $0 (FCF used to pay debt)
Total debt = $388.25m
Equity value at exit = EV − net debt − exit fees
= $2,169.51m − $388.25m − $21.70m = $1,759.56m
Initial equity = $808.8m
MOIC = $1,759.56m / $808.8m = 2.176x
IRR: Solve ( 808.8 = 1759.56 / (1+IRR)^5 ) → IRR ≈ 17.0% (annualized).
Exit multiple vs Exit-year EBITDA margin (IRR %):
| EBITDA margin → | 16.0% | 17.0% (base) | 18.0% |
|---|---|---|---|
| 9.5× | 11.5% | 13.7% | 15.8% |
| 10.5× | 13.9% | 16.0% | 18.1% |
| 11.5× | 16.2% | 18.3% | 20.3% |
Note: Calculated by adjusting FY2030 EBITDA (margin × revenue $1,215.44m), recomputing debt paydown from FY2029 end balances through FY2030 (interest/tax changes slightly), then exit EV, net debt, equity value, and IRR.
Risks:
Protection levers:
Final answer:
Base case IRR ≈ 17.0%, MOIC ≈ 2.18x, with sensitivities as above.
Turn this model response into notes, narration, or a short video
Partner link