4 models have responded to the "Ethical Dilemma with Stakeholders" challenge. Compare their approaches side-by-side on RIVAL. This response is part of RIVAL's open dataset of 5,600+ AI model responses.
Ethical Dilemma with Stakeholders
Gpt 4's response to the 'Ethical Dilemma with Stakeholders' challenge.
?Prompt
You're the CEO of a pharmaceutical company. Your best-selling drug ($2B annual revenue, used by 4 million patients for chronic pain) has just been flagged by your internal research team: a rare but serious side effect (liver failure in approximately 1 in 8,000 patients over 5 years) was missed in clinical trials and is not in the current warnings. Your legal team says formal regulatory reporting would take 6 months. Your stock price would likely drop 40% on disclosure. Three board members are pushing to "wait for more data." You have a board meeting in 48 hours and a scheduled earnings call in 72 hours. What do you do in the next 48 hours? Provide a specific, hour-by-hour action plan. Consider legal liability, ethical obligations, financial implications, PR strategy, patient safety, employee morale, and regulatory relationships. Explain the reasoning behind each decision.
Response
Day 1:
8 AM-10 AM: Convene an emergency meeting with your core leadership team. This team includes the heads of Legal, Regulatory Affairs, Medical, Research and Development, Finance, and Communications. Brief them on the situation and ask for their initial input and strategies for managing the situation.
10 AM-11 AM: Have a one-on-one meeting with the legal team to understand the full legal implications and potential liability. We must protect the company from potential lawsuits and ensure we are compliant with all laws and regulations.
11 AM-12 PM: Meet with the head of medical and research to understand the severity of the problem, the potential number of affected patients, and the possibilities for a cure or remedy.
12 PM-1 PM: Lunch.
1 PM-2 PM: Meet with the finance team to understand the financial implications, including the potential impact on the stock price, and discuss potential strategies to mitigate the financial risk.
2 PM-3 PM: Meet with the head of communications to develop a PR strategy. This includes both external communication to the general public and the media, and internal communication to employees and stakeholders.
3 PM-4 PM: Meet with the regulatory affairs team to understand the process for reporting the side effect to the regulators, and to start preparing the necessary documents.
4 PM-6 PM: Draft a preliminary plan for managing the situation, drawing on the input from the leadership team. This plan should balance legal liability, ethical obligations, financial implications, PR strategy, patient safety, employee morale, and regulatory relationships.
Day 2:
8 AM-10 AM: Review and refine the plan with the leadership team.
10 AM-12 PM: Have a meeting with the board of directors to present the situation and the plan, and to get their input and approval.
12 PM-1 PM: Lunch.
1 PM-2 PM: Based on the feedback from the board, finalize the plan.
2 PM-3 PM: Start implementing the plan, beginning with the regulatory reporting.
3 PM-4 PM: Prepare the communication to employees and stakeholders, explaining the situation in a transparent and honest way, and outlining the company's plan to address the situation.
4 PM-6 PM: Prepare the communication to the general public and the media, emphasizing the company's commitment to patient safety and our proactive steps to address the situation.
Throughout this process, it's important to remember that our top priority is patient safety. We have an ethical obligation to inform patients, the public, and regulators about the side effect as soon as possible, even though this will likely lead to a drop in the stock price. By being transparent and proactive, we can strengthen our relationships with all stakeholders and protect the company's long-term reputation and success.
Turn this model response into notes, narration, or a short video
Partner link
About GPT-4
Capabilities
Categories
Specifications
- Provider
- Openai
- Released
- 2023-05-29
- Size
- XLARGE
- Parameters
- Not disclosed
- Context
- 8,191 tokens
